tomahawKSU said:
Final thought, both Manning's have the biggest foreheads ever, and they always have the giant red mark when they take the helmets off. Just an observation.
They don't have, foreheads, they have fiveheads, lol
This young QB`s discussion is a good one, Im going to do this in tiers, NFL.Com style.
Top of the Top
Andrew Luck - I know he should be in the unproven category, but come on, he is certainly the most NFL ready QB we have seen for while, I can honestly see him playing at a high standard or many years to come, he has big boots to fill, and he`s doing an excellent job.
Matthew Stafford - Suffered from injuries early on in his career, but when he has been on the field, he has looked impressive, last year he was overshadowed by Drew Brees, but his numbers where phenomenal. I don't think the blame can be pinned on him for the slump this year, but I see he and Megatron keeping that organization competitive for a long time.
Andy Dalton - You better believe this guy is the real deal, he has played consistently well ever since his introduction to the league, there`s nothing that tells me he will slow down. AJ "Chad Who?" Green will only allow Dalton to blossom even more, with Dalton leading the team we may have to stop calling Cinci the Bungals.
Almost There
Jake Locker - has comeback well from injury, he is definitely the Titans "guy" for the future, and he is certainly better then the Titans last "Franchise QB" Vince Young, not that that`s hard. I really look forward to next year for Locker, I would love to see him avoid injury and see out a whole season, along with Kenny Britt not getting suspended and CJ running well, I could see the Titans having a good year on offense.
Josh Freeman - has done really well actually and for me as a Bucs fan it hard to remember a time when we had a reasonably trustworthy guy under center, Jeff Garcia was, but he was 53 years old.
The only thing that stops me putting him higher, is his awful season last year, accompanied with bad decision making, which is getting less and less thankfully, Freeman`s chance to prove himself is right now, he has the offense around him, he has 2 Pro Bowl G`s (though they are both on IR) V-Jax, Doug Martin and even Dallas Clark is looking helpful at the moment., Hes definitely our guy, and I think he will eventually lead us back to the post season, we just don`t know how long it will take him.
Robert Griffin III - I think he will be around for along time, and if in few years time he hasn't gone a bit coo coo like Cam because teams have film on him and are scheming against him, coupled with still playing well, then he can single handily turn the Redskins into a force in the East, and give that team the franchise leader it has so desperately needed for many years.
Still Unproven
Russell Wilson - Is certainly making a name for himself in his rookie year, and doing a good job of keeping Matt Flynn on the sideline counting his money. But can he sustain this high level? He has all the weapons right now, a great running game, good receivers and a decent D. I would like to see where he is with his development at the end of next season.
Ryan Tannerhill - He`s going to be hard to judge, hes going nice and steady for now, and I think he will continue to do so, I don`t know whether he will light the league up in the future, but I don`t think he will be bad, I see him as very average, very Miami Dolphins.
Colin Kaepernick - Yeah he looked good against the Saints, but he single handily gifted the Rams a win on Sunday with a silly error, time will tell if he can keep the job over Alex Smith.
Nick Foles - I`m a little unsure of him, but he hast played enough for me to put him anywhere else but here, the thing is, the Eagles are just a mess, I think Vick is done in Philadelphia for sure as could be Andy Reid. So if there is going to be a new starter at QB next year? Something tells me it is not going to be Nick Foles, I`m not sure what makes me think that? Just a hunch maybe? Or is it that fact that Philly will want something a little more exotic?
Unsure Of
Christian Ponder - I`m not sure what to make of him yet, sometimes he looks like a decent QB, sometimes he looks turd, I think his problem will be (as already said) his weaponry, he`s got Harvin, All Day and Rudolph, and aslong as the`re all fit I think he will be OK, but take one of those out, like at the moment with Harvin, and Ponder looks vary suspicious.
Cam Newton - Now I know he put up some monster numbers in his rookie year and made plenty of plays, but we`ve all been watching Cam for many years now, we witnessed what he did at Auburn and his rookie year, and when he`s playing well, he`s Superman Cam. But as we have seen this year, with his and the Panthers slump, Cam has really been brought back down to Earth with a bang, and this has lead to some character issues, his rant the other week was particularly interesting, this isn't school anymore Cam, Welcome to the big leagues.
Sam Bradford - Same as Ponder really, sometimes looks good sometimes looks bad, don't really have the weapons, Amendola looks decent but seems to be hurt alot of the time, Jackson probably don`t have long left. I had the pleasure of watching Bradford at this years, NFL International Series game, and he looked very average, lots of short passes, other then his long TD pass, it was all very careful, didn't really try to comeback from the Patriots big lead, he didn't turn the ball over though.
Certainly not a bad QB, I would like to see him with a top caliber receiver and maybe a half decent TE.
Lower Level
Blaine Gabbert - Lost his job to Chad Henne after a season ending injury, Henne has a huge game through the air against one of the leagues best D`s, also getting Mercedes Lewis and Justin Blackmon involved in the passing attack, providing Henne, don't blow it, I can see him being the starter over Gabbert on opening day next year.
Tim Tebow - I couldn't believe, he ended up with New York, perhaps Rex just wanted a little more razzmatazz around his team, or perhaps he wanted to put a firework up Mark Sanchez`s ass. Well the latter clearly has not worked, I think he needs to move in the off-season if he hopes to forward his career, otherwise he could continue to be the worlds most famous back up. Jacksonville would be a good spot as his hometown, it could light some more interest in that team also.
Brandon Weeden - Again you would argue he should be classified as unproven, but its the Browns, they don`t exactly have the best record of drafting QB`s, Brady Quinn, Colt McCoy, that might be harsh to Weeden, but I haven't seen anything yet that proves otherwise.
JeMarcus Russell Like
Mark Sanchez - I know he don`t have the biggest weapons to play with, but he`s been around long enough for us to see that he is infact, not vary good, he gets yanked after throwing 9 Ints, Greg McElroy comes in and wins the game.
Sanchez just is not league caliber, his decision making is awful, he has no poise, he`s just not a leader, running into his own lineman last week also? Hes simply not good enough.
John Skelton - This guy just aint the guy, I know they won a game or two under him at the start, but still, he just don`t seem like hes confident enough to lead a team, Kolb looked better when Skelton got hurt, but then he got hurt, Skelton came back and got yanked for another first time starter.
The Cards should just put Larry Fitzgerald or Patrick Peterson at QB and be done with it.