Watched the vids this morning, and aside from the shoddy camerawork, I'd say that they look pretty good.
The whole point of the ride is to simulate a dogfight between Cylon and Human spaceships. The near-collision aspect should be less pronounced than in DD, these are ships that would shoot lasers at each other, not breathe fire / use claws.
Yeah, maybe I'm looking too deep into it, but until we get some POV or actually ride the damn things, our opinions are pretty much worthless.
Mine included.