What's new

The worst roller coaster accidents

Ian

From CoasterForce
Staff member
Administrator
Moderator
Social Media Team
Theme park deaths and accidents are always a touchy subject. Yes, we're all quick to defend the parks and mention the old stat that roller coasters and rides are safer than the journey to the park, but some of them have some quite interesting backgrounds.

It was brought to my attention in an email that the worst accident of all time was in 1972 at Battersea Park fun fair in London where 5 (yes, FIVE) people died. Even today, a lady still suffers as a result: LINK

Is this the worst coaster accident in history? Do you reckon this event changed the way coasters operate? Safety belts and stricter safety checks etc.
 
1. No, I think the Mindbender accident was worse. 60mph into a concrete pillar...Ouch

2. I think it does affect the way they operate. On Hydro, they fitted the OTSR's on it as well as Perilous Plunge and newer ones
 
coasterboy said:
1. No, I think the Mindbender accident was worse. 60mph into a concrete pillar...Ouch

2. I think it does affect the way they operate. On Hydro, they fitted the OTSR's on it as well as Perilous Plunge and newer ones

Yes, ploughing into a wall at 60mph is horrific, but it's how you define "worse". Worse because more people died, or how it actually happened.
 
I was going to mention the fukin rajin accident, and the cobra acvcident last year - both could have been muich worse than they were
 
The Mindbender accident was pretty bad. And so was the incident on Cobra (which I'm riding in a few weeks).
Hydro was pretty terrible as well but then that doesn't count in a topic about 'roller coaster' accidents.
 
Reading the detailed wikipedia article on the Mindbender crash, that sounds terrible...can you imagine how scary that would have been, even watching it?
 
The Mindbender one appears worse, but I'm not sure it is. If 5 people lost their lives at Battersea and one women is potentially still suffering mentally as a result, it was undoubtably worse by defult.

I think, as sick as this sounds, the Mindbender one is just more interesting... It's an epic crash, on a fairly interesting coaster.

I don't think what happaned at the fair crash matters really, if 5 people died, it's worse than the Mindbender crash.
 
mindbender_crash.jpg


Here's a picture of the Mindbender crash.

Source:
http://www.angelfire.com/emo2/rrcr/mindbender_crash.jpg
 
^ I hate that picture with the dead body sprawled underneath the crashed train covered by a sheet, its horrific and shouldn't be posted too often.

The Mindbender accident to me is worst for some reason, probably because I can picture it more and the coaster still operates, although both are terrible.

Another one which comes to mind is the man that died on BTMR in California, that ones terrible and down to bad maintenance in a park like Disneyland is just unbelievable.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Big_Thunder_Mountain
 
I think in terms of changing the industry, the Mindbender accident takes the cake. No other accident, IMO, really affected pretty much everyone everywhere. You saw new safety things implemented and better regulations for training and inspecting overall.

Other accidents were greater in damage, but nothing beats it in terms of affect.
 
spicy said:
^ I hate that picture with the dead body sprawled underneath the crashed train covered by a sheet, its horrific and shouldn't be posted too often.
I'd never actually noticed that. Shows how much I looked at it.
 
I am supprised no one has mentioned the one from Japan when the wheel fell off on the stand up coaster. Fujin Raijin II, Expoland, Osoka, Japan.

This one is a bit close to home at the moment lol. July - Cobra, Tivoli Friheden, Aarhus, Denmark four people were injured when a coaster car broke apart.
 
southend_marc said:
I am supprised no one has mentioned the one from China when the wheel fell off on the stand up coaster. Fujin Raijin II, Expoland, Osoka, Japan.

This one is a bit close to home at the moment lol. July - Cobra, Tivoli Friheden, Aarhus, Denmark four people were injured when a coaster car broke apart.

maybe you missed it cos of my hilarious typo!

I was going to mention the fukin rajin accident, and the cobra acvcident last year - both could have been muich worse than they were
 
I am supprised no one has mentioned the one from China when the wheel fell off on the stand up coaster. Fujin Raijin II, Expoland, Osoka, Japan.

Japan isn't in China.
 
Whoops bad error to make there, thanks for spotting it will go and change it.

caffeine_demon I did miss it sorry, not having a good day lol.
 
I think when you can see footage/photos of the coaster accidents after they have happened they appear more extreme compared to others which have no footage. Like the Mindbender example without the photo it wouldn't stand out in peoples mind.

The worst case I can remember was the booster ride at a Paris fair when 2 people were killed when they were thrown from the ride.
 
The Fujin Raijin accident had pretty horrifying ramifications for the people behind the victim on the train. It also had a HUGE effect on the industry in Japan. A lot of parks have gone under as a direct reult.

There's some pretty horrific footage of an evacuation from an S&S tower ride in Asia that goes wrong in a bad, bad way. I'm fairly certain that it occured at Space World, but the footage I've seen was via a Korean news outlet.
 
SnooSnoo said:
I think in terms of changing the industry, the Mindbender accident takes the cake. No other accident, IMO, really affected pretty much everyone everywhere. You saw new safety things implemented and better regulations for training and inspecting overall.

Other accidents were greater in damage, but nothing beats it in terms of affect.

Wrong! Sorry darling.

The Battersea accident had an unbelievable affect on the UK coaster/park industry.

The industry at that time was on its knees. Cheap package holidays were killing the local parks and seaside resorts. They were operating down massively on numbers, and the only way to keep going was to cut back on maintenance.

This led directly to the Battersea coaster crash. The track was poorly maintained and the rotten wood wasn't spotted as they didn't have people out walking the tracks.

The feedback has horrendous! All of a sudden every park in the UK was put under the microscope. Every park operating a coaster they had any doubts in tore down the wood. In the few years following that accident, the UK lost more coasters than ever before. Parks folded because without a big coaster draw, the few people who would come stopped.

Those WITH coasters (Blackpool, Morecambe, Margate and Southport are four that spring to mind) found guests didn't want to ride - even though these parks had good safety records and high maintenance schedules/budgets.

It almost killed the entire UK park industry over night. Dozens of coasters torn down, parks going from major tourist attractions to nothing, people shying away from parks in their hundreds of thousands.

For a park to install a new coaster, new safety requirements were in place. Old coasters needed to be overhauled and to comply with stricter regulations (nothing like today, but the Grand National had to finally have restraints added for instance).

So the repercussions of the accident were felt right around the UK in a huge way. I suspect in the world too - did PTC have cars with restraints prior to that point?

The saviour was Geoffery Thompson at Blackpool. Instead of shying away, he invested in new "steel" technology, and showed the public you could have safe and reliable new rides, running alongside old and reliable (and safe) old rides. His success with this strategy (caused entirely by a lack of faith in wooden coasters due to the Battersea incident) caught on and created the UK Theme Park boom of the 80's. Out of the ashes and all that. We're still seeing the problems. Rhyl and several other seaside resorts that have shut in the last ten years, have done so mainly because they tore down their wooden signature rides after the accident.

They limped on for a few years, but without that wooden draw to their parks - they all gradually faded away, while the likes of Blackpool shone on.

So, erm, yeah - Battersea probably carried the most weight of any accident so far :)
 
I think when you can see footage/photos of the coaster accidents after they have happened they appear more extreme compared to others which have no footage. Like the Mindbender example without the photo it wouldn't stand out in peoples mind.

Hum, good point.
I think a lot of times we'll look at a picture, compared to an article, and say that the accident with the picture was worse.
Just reading about how many people died never really sticks.

^ I hate that picture with the dead body sprawled underneath the crashed train covered by a sheet, its horrific and shouldn't be posted too often.
I never really noticed that!
UGH....
 
Top