Just picking rides from my top 9 woods and top 15 steels which you can see
here. I've only been on 20 something woods so my top list looks like **** after #5. Anyways to the topic.
Grizzly @ King's Dominion: I rode this back when I was 6 waaaaaaay back in 1999. I remember it being fully wooded and just so much fun that I actually remembered a good part of it over 13 years later to where I rode it in April. A lot has happened in those 13 years. Hypersonic tore away all the trees on the Hurler side of the coaster and DinosAlive tore out a good chunk of other trees on the opposite side, totally retracting from the old, heavily wooded version I loved as a 6 year old. The ride is still a barrel of fun, but the lack of trees really cuts away at the sense of speed and detracts from the overall experience.
Comet @ Hersheypark: The second half of this definitely has more potential if the trim goes. A friend of mine said it used to compare to Phoenix in terms of air time. Having Skyrush to play with is actually a plus for excitement because it makes it feel like the ride is way tighter in terms of space than it actually is.
Skyrush @ Hersheypark: yeah this thing definitely is a world top 5 steel, there's no denying it. I'm very glad Intamin went with pseudo-lap bars instead of those horrid OTSRs but the padding is just ugly, and the new harnesses are barely helping from what I hear.
Maverick @ Cedar Point: Get rid of the OTSRs and you have a winner.
Intimidator 305 @ King's Dominion: Get rid of the OTSRs and that bunny hill trim and it would really bump this thing higher into my top 10.
Not on the list but deserve mention:
Millennium Force: If there was force after the first drop I wouldn't be talking about this.
Raptor @ Cedar Point: Needs more force, the inversions and twists look like they pack a punch but they don't.
Steel Force @ Dorney Park: Needs more air time, and for the MCBR to not trip on the second half.
Volcano @ King's Dominion: Needs more force in the launch(es) and also needs a big time cleaning and covering in the volcano itself.
Hellcat / J2 / Tsunami @ Clementon Park: Remove the trim and smooth it out, and it definitely will live up to its 2004 self.